If you were lucky enough to listen to my outgoing voicemail message as a teen, you would have heard the sultry voice of El Pachuco, the effortlessly cool and proud defender of the Chicanx psyche in Luis Valdez’s Zoot Suit. Part man, part myth, all swagger, El Pachuco as played by Edward James Olmos was the idealized incarnation of the Chicano farmworker’s alter ego, a person who could make for himself what the Anglo world denied him. Doing my very best impression of Olmos in Zoot Suit, I let the caller know that “Fighting The Man takes time, but when I get his hands off of my neck, I’ll call you back.” As a Chicanx kid raised by grandparents who grew up in the ’40s and ’50s, I came to see the pachuco as a cultural touchpoint. I understood early that El Pachuco’s speech and dress personified Chicanx’s desire to stand in their power. With mine and many Chicano families being farmworkers and because of the carnage and despair of the fields, El Pachuco wasn’t just a way of being—he was the way, showing that to call your countrymen “carnal” was a call to arms.
The documentary American Pachuco: The Legend of Luis Valdez explores this call through the rebellious mind of his creator, the titular famed playwright and filmmaker. Narrated by El Pachuco himself, Olmos leads the audience through the stages of Valdez’s life and career, from his formative experience with theater at 6 years old, through his days as a playwright with the United Farm Workers union, to his work on his hit films Zoot Suit and La Bamba.
A part of PBS’ American Masters series, the film celebrates an iconic artist with aplomb. To tell Valdez’s larger-than-life tale, director David Alvarado blends archival footage with interviews with cultural heavy hitters like Dolores Huerta, Cheech Marin, and Linda Ronstadt to give a sense of the enormous impact the playwright had on the Chicanx community. Through their eyes and the words of Valdez and his siblings—Danny, Socorro, and his late older brother, Frank—the film paints a portrait of a person with an indomitable desire to create and a sincere belief that performance is a practical way of changing the world.
Early scenes of Dolores Huerta describing him as a “social arsonist” over archival footage of a young, cigar-chomping, bigote-sporting Valdez organizing and galvanizing the fields with his Actos, farmworker produced one-act plays, convey the militancy of the early years of the UFW and the ingenuity of Teatro Campesino as a whole. These performances in their original moment alongside remarks from Chicano scholar Jorge A. Huerta about “Valdez’s rebellion through words” makes clear the exigency of changing the working and living conditions for migrant farmworkers .
But a legend is also a key, a guide for understanding how to move through space. This is the true value of this documentary: understanding the landscape of Chicanx identity and history and the manifold directions in which it moves through his life and work. Much of this kind of exploration in the film centers on the tensions between Luis and his older brother, Frank, who aims for acceptance among white folks. While Valdez put his Chicano culture at the forefront, Frank tested the limits of assimilation for Mexican Americans in his career as an Air Force engineer. This could be a plotline from one of Valdez’s Actos, and indeed, he openly acknowledges that Frank was the inspiration for a number of characters featured in his work.
This is one of the more powerful moments in the film, one that merits a more complete telling of its own. With this familial and cultural tension so stark, I thought this portion of the film could be subtitled “The Pachuco and the Pocho,” as I was struck by how much the division between the brothers’ identities manifested through a division of labor: Luis a storyteller, and Frank a literal rocket scientist building weapons for use in Vietnam. In a moment in time when it’s unfathomable that Latinos could hunt their own as Immigration and Custom Enforcement agents, the Valdez brothers’ feud over racial and cultural identity feels especially relevant.
As good as American Pachuco is at celebrating Valdez’s artistic achievements, it does leave some loose threads. In depicting Valdez’s early career with the United Farm Workers, the film addresses his relationship with Cesar Chavez and, in doing so, acknowledges Chavez’s history of sexual assault. However, the film tries to sidestep this rather awkwardly. Instead of tackling it head-on, there’s only one mention of it, coming from Olmos: “We thought Cesar was one of us. We held him up as a saint—but history would tell a different story down the line.”
This brief line is a missed opportunity. American Pachuco is steadfast that Dolores Huerta was the true champion of Teatro Campesino and, as Valdez explains in the doc, a “theater of, by, and for farmworkers,” and paints Chavez as apathetic to the endeavor. But this only raises more questions about the power dynamics among the three. Valdez is a writer who has endured due to his insight. His Actos are so bitingly clear on the emotional and psychological effects of power that it is bizarre not to hear or feel any of his reactions to this particular abuse of power in the UFW. It was a chance to once again show why Dolores. Huerta’s description of him as a “social arsonist” is still true today. This conspicuous absence warps a bit of the fabric of the story, recasting an earlier line from Valdez on migrant farm labor conditions in California—“it’s an injustice when you think about it; it’s unbearable when you have to live through it”—as a description of Dolores Huerta’s experience in the UFW.
Likewise, Valdez’s post–La Bamba life is notably missing. There’s little sense of his life between the 1990s and today, with only brief scenes of him addressing crowds at honorary events, intimating that he still acts as a mentor to Chicanxs in the film industry. Similarly, the documentary shows his current engagement with theater only through shots of him around contemporary productions, with little else on how he’s spent nearly four decades.
Thinking back to my own performance of El Pachuco, I realize I didn’t fully understand then what I was borrowing with the voice. I thought El Pachuco was about style: the tone of voice and the attitude. What Valdez understood, and what this film captures at its best, is that style is always strategy, a way for families who worked themselves to the bone in the fields to show that their world matters to everyone. In all, American Pachuco is a worthy tribute and a reminder that the fights Valdez dramatized are far from over. Fighting The Man takes time. But somewhere, El Pachuco is still adjusting his brim, waiting for the line to ring, ready to call us back.